Attention Curve: The Capital Market for Good
In a recent conversation with Tony Audino, a Seattle-based entrepreneur and VC friend of mine, we talked about the blended value market and its various market sectors, both old and new. At one point he said “you know you should develop a “hype curve” for this market.
Hype curves are most frequently associated with Gartner Group’s technology charts that measure market visibility and maturity ranging from an initial “technology trigger” to a “plateau of productivity” along a curve just like the one below. However the nomenclature utilized there is not appropriate for the blended value market. What you see below is an adaptation of the general hype curve idea that I call an “attention curve.”

A “social trigger” occurs when some new way of creating both social and financial value is developed and begins to spread. New social enterprises are born and some level of acceptance of the idea emerges among a group of insiders. This initial success may or may not be driven by a new technology. In many cases such as microfinance or fair trade, a new bargain is struck and/or a new series of transactions are created or redefined. In any case this social trigger allows others to see and do things differently that result in the creation of both social and financial value. Attention follows and soon an emerging market sector is born.
Typically this attention follows a curve upward until a level of “peak attention” is reached, most recently exemplified by the way everything has gone “green” - from special popular magazine issues on the subject to the Oscars and Al Gore’s Inconvenient Truth.
Of course from this point there is no place to go but down in terms of attention. It is in this down cycle where the sector shows its mettle. While significant attention usually brings a flow of new money, these new ideas have to actually work or they slowly disappear off the radar. This is the period I call “market acceptance.” The idea either proves to be sustainable or it falls off the chart. If indeed it proves out, a more mature period of expansion and development occurs supported by smart money. In the case of clean technology for example, this has meant a quadrupling of venture investment in the last six years. Ultimately the acceptance of the idea becomes so commonplace that “market liquidity” develops as it has with the affordable housing market.
Admittedly, the positioning of certain sectors on the attention curve is somewhat subjective. To help guide my judgment I used Technorati’s charting tool that shows the number of hits on keywords over time from the 84.6 million blogs it tracks. Here is the Technorati chart on “green” for example.
Certainly there are other methods for determining positioning on the curve that we at Collective Intelligence intend to explore, but for this first pass, I offer it up as is. The attention chart points out that blended value has been around for a long time, with serious market successes to point to. It also says there is a lot more where that came from, a wave of new ideas, companies and non-profits, albeit at different stages of maturity, that are following on the heals of their predecessors. I’d love to hear your comments and suggestions.
Thanks Mark
PS You can continue to follow the development of this chart and how these market sectors play out at collectiveintelligence.net.

entities
entities

June 5th, 2007 um 8:54 am
it will be interesting to track this over time. and maybe make a version people can move the sliders on
June 5th, 2007 um 11:00 am
Very cool. I wonder how volitile the curve is, and whether there is a third dimension of momentum (or growth) that can be charted as well.
June 5th, 2007 um 11:13 am
rupert do you mean the speed with which a particular sector is moving on the curver? that is a great idea. using technorati (for now) i would compare increased attention say between two dates and assign a color or something to each square. measuring growth in the field is more difficult, but something xigi wants to do.
thanks rupert.
|||b
June 5th, 2007 um 10:33 pm
Not astoundingly different from the curves in the Chasm and Tornado Moore books. Awareness, hype, turmoil, acceptance, commodity, etc. But, building the chart dynamically based on attention factors like media mentions, digg’s, quarterly grant gifts, VC investments in various sectors, etc. would be cool. Best of luck, Steve.
June 6th, 2007 um 4:10 am
Of course, adoption and attention are similar; we didn’t invent the curve at all. It’s an adaptation of an existing form into a new venue with a new set of parameters.
June 6th, 2007 um 8:41 am
Steve thanks for pointing out Moore. I had not really seen his charts before (here are a couple: http://www.acuity-mi.com/Technology_Markets.html ), but know his work otherwise. Agree there are great possibilities for a dynamic chart that is based on the factors you mention and others. We intend to explore them fully. Would love to chat about it as we get further down the road.
June 8th, 2007 um 4:37 pm
Very interesting. I’d be curious
(1) how you plotted the “maturity” of these concepts
(2) if you could overlay an adoption curve. This could show the lag between attention and adoption
June 22nd, 2007 um 7:45 am
yes mark please unpack the way you put this together for us…i think we’d all be interested. and i second the add on project idea of adding adoption curve overlay. course, have to figure out how to figure THAT!
July 18th, 2007 um 10:54 am
[…] To view the full article by Mark Beam, click here. […]
August 4th, 2007 um 7:26 pm
Admittedly, the positioning of certain sectors on the attention curve is somewhat subjective. To help guide my judgment I used Technorati’s charting tool that shows the number of hits on keywords over time from the 84.6 million blogs it tracks. Here is the Technorati chart on “green” for example.
Since this overall concept has received a fair amount of interest I am currently refining a methodology. If anyone has particular ideas or strong recommendations, including characteristics of the support data I would love to hear them.
September 28th, 2007 um 1:06 pm
[…] http://www.xigi.net/2007/06/04/attention-curve-the-capital-market-for-good.html […]